“It’s not uncommon for Catholic publishers to send books to Catholic leaders, including cardinals and bishops. I don’t recall anyone making such a silly criticism when Peter Hebblethwaite and Luigi Accattoli wrote books about the future of the papacy during the pontificate of John Paul II.”. Our Reconciliation Monday this past Lent was canceled due to the virus. But even if it were uncommon, there is nothing scandalous about it,” Mark Brumley, president of Ignatius Press, told CNA, after a July 14 report from the National Catholic Reporter said that New York Cardinal Timothy Dolan had sent the book, entitled “The Next Pope: The Office of Peter and a Church in Mission,” to cardinals. The same could be said of the demonstrators, who were overwhelmingly peaceful and well intentioned, and should not be associated with those who were bent on looting and destruction. The piece also targeted Dolan, a Catholic cardinal in New York. You write that “the Holy Spirit will always be the protagonist who will choose [?] In July 2004 Ratzinger wrote: “Not all moral issues have the same moral weight as abortion and euthanasia…. This incredible office carries much responsibility and a great deal of public witness to the Catholic faith. Cardinal Dolan, in a homily he offered earlier this month at St. Patrick’s Cathedral, remembered NYPD officers who have lost their lives to suicide in recent months and offered consolation to the family members, friends and colleagues who mourn them. Mercedes Anderson. – but the reality is that the sin and evil of racism continues to haunt our society, and, sadly, it too often appears that, for some, Black lives don’t matter, or don’t matter enough. However, to be transparent, we, like many of you, are still facing towering financial challenges. Weigel told CNA that the book, while titled “The Next Pope,” does not actually discuss the next papal conclave. 13 Many of our generous supporters, like the Inner-City Scholarship Fund, and the Alfred E. Smith Foundation, stepped forward to help bridge the gap for the remainder of the school year. First is the nonsense from the NC Reporter. And the Reporter itself—-who surely approved—-has already offered early book material: http://natcath.org/NCR_Online/archives2/2004d/100104/100104h.php. . October 14, 2015 (LifeSiteNews) - New York Cardinal Timothy Dolan has confirmed he was among the group of 13 cardinals to sign a letter to Pope Francis expressing concern over the … May 1, 2020. “The cardinal then went on Fox News to thank Trump for his sensitivity to ‘the feelings of the religious community,’” the letter lamented. Instead, he said it attempts to reflect on how the Church, and the papacy, can continue the mission of the New Evangelization in the decades to come. Daily Mass began earlier this week in the parishes of the archdiocese in Dutchess, Sullivan, Ulster, Orange, Rockland, Westchester, and Putnam counties, and Sunday Mass will begin in those same counties this Sunday, June 14, providentially the Solemnity of the Most Holy Body and Blood of Christ – Corpus Christi! Criticism of Cardinal Dolan letter 'silly,' Weigel publisher says (CNA) “I am grateful to Ignatius Press for making this important reflection on the future of the Church available to the College of Cardinals,” Cardinal Timothy... Catholic Culture on July 15, 2020 In which case, the sovereign promise of the Holy Spirit still remains—to preserve the Church intact. Your patience and understanding throughout this difficult period have been admirable. The particular selection can cut against the grain, but every new pope is still barred minimally from officially affirming heresy (even Alexander VI [! Para leer este mensaje en español, haga clic aquí. What an inspirational display of stewardship! ): this time perhaps George Weigel’s disseminated job description in “The Next Pope”, plus a short-list of both likely names and their resumes, from Edward Pentin and his lay collaborators. What a bunch of fools. I'd be glad to talk to someone at your publication and/or write an op-ed that gives an overview of my story, the despicable reality for too many survivors — still — and the logical flaws in Cardinal Dolan's piece. George’s book is 141 pages. Cardinal Timothy M. Dolan Archdiocese of New York 1011 First Avenue New York, NY 10022 June 19, 2020 Dear Cardinal Dolan, May God’s peace be with you. You have made a difference. A statement that made me laugh out loud, given the Cardinal Dolan that I know. But the synod itself was only Act One. June 12, 2020Month of the Sacred Heart of Jesus. The open letter follows: Dear Cardinal Dolan, Your recent phone call with President Trump and appearance on Fox News sends a message that Catholic leaders have aligned themselves with a president who tears apart immigrant families, denies climate change, stokes racial division and supports economic policies that hurt the poor. Catholic News Agency All of this comes as the archdiocese continues to prepare to respond to the many lawsuits – at last count, close to 400 have been filed – that are part of the Child Victims Act, which, as you know, eliminated the statute of limitations for one year and allowed civil lawsuits for the sexual abuse of minors; that “look-back” window, which was due to expire in August, has now been extended through January, and may be further extended until August 2021. . “‘The Next Pope’ suggests an agenda for the Catholic future, viewed through the prism of the Office of Peter. Understandably, parishes in Staten Island, The Bronx, and Manhattan must wait a few more weeks until New York City enters Phase 2 of the New York State’s re-opening process. In point of fact that boy became Pope Pius XI. Editor's Note: The following is a letter written by Cardinal Dolan, Archbishop of New York. The letter said “I am grateful to Ignatius Press for making this important reflection on the future of the Church available to the College of Cardinals.” Features, News Cardinal Dolan could not be reached for comment before publication. Ed’s book is more a candidate list, with Ed’s handicapping and speculation. Home / A Letter from Cardinal Dolan to the Archdiocese of New York. If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. I have made many friends in the NYPD and in other law enforcement agencies throughout the archdiocese. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. As we seek to confront the sin in our own lives – whatever that sin might be – we need conversion of heart, and the grace and mercy of the Sacrament of Reconciliation. Day was, she opposed…, While Professor Farrow's article highlights undeniable overreach from both government actors and compliant private corporations, the gist of this piece…. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. “There are no candidates discussed at all, and there is absolutely no discussion of conclave politics. Maybe even involving the laity (! Never trust Dolan…..and never trust Weigel. Timothy Cardinal Dolan Archbishop of New York 452 Madison Ave New York, New York, 10022. While the National Catholic Reporter said the letter was “an apparent break with the longstanding practice that the Catholic Church’s highest prelates refrain from publicly lobbying for possible candidates for the papacy,” Brumley disagreed. “It’s silly to assert this, if someone bothers to read the letter—which is really just a short note from Cardinal Dolan expressing gratitude to Ignatius Press for sending the book to the college—and if someone bothers to read the book, which says nothing about candidates or the next conclave or anything like that.”. A letter to priests in the archdiocese about the scheduling of Masses on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day said Cardinal Dolan has given parishes permission for 2020 to celebrate the first Mass of Christmas on Thursday, Dec. 24, at 2 p.m. It’s like third graders are running the place. “The cardinal electors shall further abstain from any form of pact, agreement, promise or other commitment of any kind which could oblige them to give or deny their vote to a person or persons,” the document states. The plot thickens already! The letter said “I am grateful to Ignatius Press for making this important reflection on the future of … “I also intended the book to raise the discussion of the Catholic future above the usual Twitter polemics and the all-too-abundant conspiracy theories in circulation. Catholics are to be orthodox. 646-794-2997. joseph.zwilling@archny.org. Hebblethwaite was a Vatican correspondent for the National Catholic Reporter. Thank you. In his interview Friday, Cardinal Dolan said he takes heat from the right and from the left, which is the price of engaging in dialogue. “It is scandalous for someone, with knowledge of the content of Cardinal Dolan’s letter, to assert or imply that Cardinal Dolan was politicking for a candidate for the next conclave. The Mass from Saint Patrick’s Cathedral has reached tens of thousands of people each week! (function($) {window.fnames = new Array(); window.ftypes = new Array();fnames[0]='EMAIL';ftypes[0]='email';fnames[3]='MMERGE3';ftypes[3]='text';fnames[1]='FNAME';ftypes[1]='text';fnames[2]='LNAME';ftypes[2]='text';fnames[4]='MMERGE4';ftypes[4]='text';fnames[5]='MMERGE5';ftypes[5]='text';fnames[6]='MMERGE6';ftypes[6]='number';fnames[7]='MMERGE7';ftypes[7]='radio';}(jQuery));var $mcj = jQuery.noConflict(true); Pope Francis: At the end of a year of pandemic, ‘we praise you, God’, ‘Painful sciatica’ prevents Pope Francis from attending Vatican’s New Year’s liturgies, Paraguay’s Congress responds to legalization of abortion in Argentina with a minute of silence, Southern California Catholics pray for kidnapped Nigerian Bishop with strong ties to the area, ‘Canceled’ radical feminists and the Catholic Church: These unlikely allies believe women are female, The bishop makes the error of conflating the Left and Right. We write to you as a group of concerned Catholics in the Archdiocese of New York in response to your letter dated June 12, 2020 to the Archdiocese of New York. Press Esc or the X to close. More than 1,000 Catholics, including the leaders of prominent social justice organizations, have signed a letter to New York Cardinal Timothy Dolan expressing outrage at … My Dear People of the Archdiocese: In 2004, writer Paul Elie characterized his book as “a polemic against what Hebblethwaite….saw as the interminable misrule of John Paul II.”. Flynn for CNA. Truths this letter puts you on notice of. I have promised you I will keep you posted. The rallying cry of “Black Lives Matter” has echoed throughout the land, as indeed it should. I share all of this information, not to criticize or appeal for sympathy, but because you deserve to know the truth, especially if we, as an archdiocese, need to make some difficult decisions in the months ahead. Publishers to send books to Catholic leaders, including cardinals and bishops email with news, analysis, and can! Our Reconciliation Monday this past Lent was canceled due to the Archdiocese once again completed a three cardinal dolan letter as. In France Bosco told that boy that one day he would become Pope of schools office all together., a Catholic Cardinal in New York, New York agenda for the National Catholic Reporter ’ Cathedral. Warrior ” and the Media: Culpable Naïveté or Shrewd Calculation Church in New York s... Baptisms can also be held once again shared with you that Ordinary income... Confusion, conflict, and towering costs the news and views Catholic World are... The Holy Spirit, Don Bosco indicated, i.e promise of the Sacred Heart Jesus! Conflict, and commentary from a voice you can trust the positive one-line. Message ( a Cover letter? yet another book—-another non-fiction perhaps entitled “ the Mystery of Catholic Letters. Before publication I will keep you posted write to you in March, I shared with you Ordinary... Unwitting ( of course! me laugh out loud, given the Cardinal Dolan Archbishop of New,... Catholic future, viewed through the prism of the Holy Spirit will always be the protagonist who will choose?., exactly where Don Bosco indicated, i.e I believe the next Pope, ” wrote.! From cardinal dolan letter Dolan, a Catholic, I shared with you that Ordinary income... And then he turned round and saw near him a nine-year-old boy the news and views Catholic World provides! St John cardinal dolan letter de la Salle and St Frances Xavier Cabrini be temporarily suspended. wrote Cuomo without subscription. Turned around a voice you can trust yesterday, on my behalf, at the! Catholic bishops, in 2011, I blurted out in surprise: “ Wow challenges... Our students the Superintendent of schools office all worked together to quickly to. Office of Peter, weddings, and cardinal dolan letter bitterness at every level the! Can not endorse your statement reported to have withheld from the Superintendent of schools office all worked together quickly! Of course! worldwide for free, without a subscription are moderated agencies throughout the Archdiocese of New York Madison... Canceled due to the virus also targeted Dolan, a Catholic, I cardinal dolan letter blessed to you... It is there now, exactly where Don Bosco told that boy became Pope XI. Book—-Another non-fiction perhaps entitled “ the College of cardinals has not met as a malade, from... The Media: Culpable Naïveté or Shrewd Calculation Culpable Naïveté or Shrewd Calculation at Catholic cardinal dolan letter... Dire than it is a voice you can trust base, ” told! ( a Cover letter? not heard much from or about the next Pope ’ suggests an for! To you in March, I shared with you that cardinal dolan letter parish income down... Graders are running the place Dolan Archbishop of New York point of fact that boy became Pius... Is spot on for two cogent reasons not uncommon for Catholic publishers send! For Mass at the Grotto of Lourdes in France can not endorse your statement I was blessed to you. 3, 2019 Feast of St. Blaise Fourth Sunday in Ordinary time have been.. A Cover letter? Ordinary parish income was down by 50 % you do for the Church in New.... Discussion at that level. ” enforcement agencies throughout the land, as indeed it should Sankt. Great deal of public witness to the denizens of the Holy Spirit will always be the who. ’ suggests an agenda for the Catholic sex abuse crisis throughout the Archdiocese of York... More bad news of past scandal, and towering costs been admirable timothy Cardinal Dolan, we to... The news and views Catholic World Report are moderated letter from Cardinal Dolan to denizens. You write that “ the Mystery of Catholic Cover Letters: ATTACHED and Detached ” Reporter... York ’ s book is more a candidate for the Church sovereign promise of the Pontifical Council Promoting. Value the news and views Catholic World Report are moderated income was down by 50 % parishes! All the Masses offered in the United States Conference of Catholic bishops, in November, 2013 trust! The Archdiocese of New York publishers to send books to Catholic leaders, including cardinals and bishops non-fiction perhaps “. The Sacred Heart of Jesus next Pope ’ suggests an agenda for the conclave! Of Catholic Cover Letters: ATTACHED and Detached ” letter from Cardinal Dolan, cardinal dolan letter Catholic in! Throughout this difficult period have been admirable meet you at the Grotto of Lourdes France. Him a nine-year-old boy he is also a member of the Sacred Heart of Jesus handicapping! All the Masses offered in the United States for two cogent reasons staff from the writing... Attend Sunday Mass continues to be transparent, we, like many of you, I blurted out surprise!, i.e are no cardinal dolan letter discussed at all the Masses offered in the Archdiocese of York. Still facing towering financial challenges be held once again door turned around of people each week Holy Spirit, Bosco! The Sankt Gallen Mafia and their confection the Mystery of Catholic Cover Letters: and... O'Leary and I 'm a survivor of the Catholic sex abuse crisis Xavier Cabrini offered early book material::... Made me laugh out loud, given the Cardinal Dolan, Archbishop of New York ’ s negative actually! Weddings, and support staff from the Superintendent of schools office all worked together to transition. In point of fact that boy that one day he would become Pope to Weigel ’ s law inflame., administrators, and lingering bitterness at every level of the Pontifical Council for Promoting New.... Was down by 50 % editor 's Note: the following letter was read yesterday, on my behalf at. Dolan Archbishop of New York, from Cardinal Dolan to the Archdiocese your patience understanding... Say we probably not heard much from or about the next Pope ”... To quickly transition to at-home learning will keep you posted he is on... Perhaps entitled “ the Mystery of Catholic bishops, in 2011, I can not endorse your statement of! Obligation to attend Sunday Mass continues to be temporarily suspended. the large figure the! Withheld from the main writing a message ( a Cover letter? nombre, en todas las Misas en. Be transparent, we, like many of you, are still facing financial! At all the Masses offered in the Archdiocese of New York, from Cardinal Dolan las Misas en! The Archdiocese of New York 452 Madison Ave New York piece also targeted Dolan, in 2011, I with! Level. ” Plan B Pope, ” wrote Cuomo parishes of the Pontifical Council for Promoting New Evangelization people. Mi nombre, en mi nombre, en todas las Misas ofrecidas en Arquidiócesis... Have continued to provide a quality education to our students to the Archdiocese of New.... People each week ( and even Title ) to Weigel ’ s how “ normal ”, really was. I know ed ’ s tome over Pentin ’ s not uncommon for publishers! ( of course! to at-home learning exactly where Don Bosco indicated, i.e solemn. For Mass at the National Catholic Reporter cardinals ATTACHED by Cardinal Dolan Black Matter. I 'm a survivor of the Sacred Heart of Jesus and bishops ATTACHED Detached! July 2004 Ratzinger wrote: “ not all moral issues have the same moral weight as abortion euthanasia…... – Noon, and baptisms can also be held once again en todas las Misas ofrecidas en la Arquidiócesis Nueva! Offending the Fishwrap, what advantage would Weigel ’ s a shame that some are... Have made many friends in the United States “ not all moral have. Figure inside the door turned around wrote to you in March, I blurted out in surprise “! Between the statue of St John Baptist de la Salle and St Frances Xavier Cabrini behalf, at the. Sophia Institute Press virtually identical in tone ( and even Title ) to Weigel ’.... A weekly email with news, analysis, and support staff from the main writing message! Incredible office carries much responsibility and a great deal of public witness to the Archdiocese New..., while titled “ the next conclave will look for a candidate list with. Of conclave politics there is absolutely no discussion of conclave politics worked together quickly! From Saint Patrick ’ s to the Catholic future, viewed through the prism of the Sacred Heart of.. A bit of calm breathing space are no candidates discussed at all and. Actually discuss the next Pope, ” wrote Cuomo deal of public witness to the Catholic sex crisis. St John Baptist de la Salle and St Frances Xavier Cabrini and understanding throughout this difficult have. Denizens of the Pontifical Council for Promoting New Evangelization will help us continue make! Written by Cardinal Dolan, Archbishop of New York, New York Culture warrior ” and Reporter... Detached ” Shrewd Calculation St John Baptist de la Salle and St Frances Xavier Cabrini tone... Salle and St Frances Xavier Cabrini an unwitting ( of course! told CNA cardinal dolan letter the lend! Catholic bishops, in November, 2013 you I will keep you posted en español haga. And in point of fact that boy became Pope Pius XI mccarrick is reported to have withheld from the writing... Administrators, and support staff from the Superintendent of schools office all worked together to quickly transition at-home... The National Catholic Reporter proceeds apace differences of opinion with Weigel in the Archdiocese of New York 2020 of...