Grilling the perfect Tomahawk ribeye steak requires time and patience. Tonight's dinner was a reverse sear Costco Tomahawk steak cooked on my GMG pellet grill.Seasoning was simple Montral steak seasoning with additional salt.Served with asparagus, tomato avocado salad and hollandaise sauce.This was so tender and juicy! Steaks Over 1.5 Inches Thick – Reverse Sear Method of Start it Low, Finish with a Sear. But "big ol' honkin' steaks" do best with combination cooking techniques, like reverse sear, sous vide, or sear/roast. Because this ribeye steak is an extra thick (think 1 1/2-2″) prime ribeye with a portion of the rib bone still attached, it is great for this method of cooking. Then you should have your grill. Cooking the Steak- Direct heat is fine for steaks in the 1" neighborhood. BBQ – Reverse Sear. How to Reverse Sear a Steak. The tomahawk ribeye I purchased from Appalachian Meats was just shy of three pounds, unless you want to round it up. Light the charcoals and move to one side of the grill when hot. Over direct or high heat on the grill, place the tomahawk steaks. Sear both sides for 1-2 minutes, then reduce to medium heat and continue to grill for the times listed in the chart below. While the pork is resting, place up to 2 tablespoons of the compound butter on each steak. It's when you create a beautiful sear on the outside of a wood-fired smoked steak. Tomahawk Ribeye Steak Recipe The Tomahawk Ribeye Steak is a specialty cut steak that you probably won’t find at your local supermarket. I did a reverse-sear which means I first slow-cooked the meat to a perfect internal temperature, ... to this beautiful and Flintstone-sized Tomahawk steak on the grill. 1. When it comes to quality steak, I always get mine from Snake River Farms. The process of reverse-searing is really simple: Season a roast or a thick-cut steak (the method works best with steaks at least one and a half to two inches thick), arrange the meat on a wire rack set in a rimmed baking sheet, and place it in a low oven—between 200 and 275°F (93 and 135°C). 2. Sear for two minutes per side or until the internal temperature of the steak reaches 140 degrees F. Remove from grill and let rest for 10 minutes. It’s hard to beat a tomahawk steak with its phenomenal look and precious marbling! Let your steaks come to room temperature. Remove the steak from the grill, allowing it to rest while your grill preheats. Reverse Sear Tomahawk Steak the Professional Way. Another approach using the BBQ is the reverse sear. Season as desired. You want the grill to reach about 275 degrees Fahrenheit on the side furthest from the hot burner. Lol – the best way to cook thicker steaks. Reverse Seared Ribeyes. Once you have chosen your prize, it's time for prep. These were huge steaks, about 18 inches long. It will slowly start to melt over the steak. This bad boy Wagyu Tomahawk Steak weighs in at a whopping 3.5 pounds and is about 2.5 inches thick. How to Grill a Tomahawk Ribeye. Ingredients: Tomahawk Ribeye, Butcher Shop Steak Rub, Organic Butcher Black Garlic and Rosemary Compound Butter. This Tomahawk Ribeye Steak is an extra thick (think 1 1/2-2”) prime ribeye with a portion of the rib bone still attached. This cut is full of flavor and Traeger Pro Team Member Matt Pittman knows how to do it best. What is reverse searing? Serve this sliced and hot off the grill with your favorite side dishes like baked potatoes and veggies. You should grill these steaks on indirect heat and finish with the reverse sear over direct heat. With the lid down, preheat grill with one burner on medium and the other burners turned off. Reverse Sear – Charcoal Grilling Instructions. Place seasoned steaks on opposite side of charcoals. Learn how to reverse sear steak to get the best grill marks and flavor. If you’ve never grilled a Tomahawk steak because you’re unsure of how to grill it correctly, you’re missing out. Jun 22, 2019 - tips and tricks to cooking the perfect tomahawk ribeye. How To Reverse-Sear a Steak on your Pellet Grill. 5. It is arguably – and believe me, people do argue it a lot! Pending on how you like your steaks cooked (medium rare, right? As Meathead Goldwyn discusses on amazingribs.com the history of the reverse sear technique can be traced back to the sous vide pioneers in the 1970s. To cook on a gas grill, preheat on high. Preheat oven to 275°F. Meathead and J. Kenji Lopez-Alt from seriouseats.com have been two of the more prominent advocates of the technique over the past 10 years and for good reason! You’ll slowly bring the steaks up to temperature in a low oven or on the cool side of a charcoal grill, and then sear the steaks on the stovetop or hot side of the grill. It should take about 20 minutes to reach about 115 degrees F. Now they’re ready for the real heat. The tomahawk ribeye (or cowboy cut ribeye) is a specialty cut ribeye steak. The length of the bone made them hard to work with – the two steaks took up half of my kettle grill, and every time I turned or flipped them I had to adjust, so the bone wasn’t hanging over the edge of the grill. Preheat your grill and keep temperatures around 325-350 degrees. While we’re going through a lot of groceries each week, in the end, we’re saving a lot by eating well, at home. This technique is almost universally agreed upon as the best way to cook steaks. Here’s what I thought of his reverse-sear technique. Move the steaks over the hot part of the grill. If you’ve struggled with getting your steaks perfect or just want to take your grilling game to the next level, try reverse-searing at your next barbecue. Mix butter with garlic and horseradish and place a few pats on each steak. I had to ask my butcher to specially cut these bad boys, but it’s worth the extra effort. Reverse Sear a Tomahawk Steak. Set aside at room temperature while the grill heats. https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/246229/grilling-thick-steaks-the-reverse-sear Now, it may be called a tomahawk steak, but what they look like is a fireman’s axe. The reason we do this is because of the thickness of the steak. Rub the oil into both sides of the steaks and then season evenly with the salt and pepper. This cut of steak isn’t one where you can flash-sear in a pan for two minutes on each side. You can do the reverse sear on the gas grill, charcoal grill, kamado, and even pellet grill. The reverse sear technique is the best way to cook a thick cut steak. It is also perfect for this reverse sear steak “How To”! Sear steak for one minute on each side. Sear a thick steak for about 3-5 minutes total flipping constantly (every 15-30 seconds). Make dinner epic with the perfect reverse seared Tomahawk. Make sure you season these steaks liberally because they are so thick. Grill steaks until internal temperature reaches 120° F. 4. 6. 3. Nope. For any steak over 1.5 inches thick, the reverse sear method is fantastic. Place steaks on a wire rack over a baking sheet. Set up a two zone cooking method. Sear the tomahawk steak for 1 to 2 minutes per side over high heat until satisfying sear marks form. The first and easily most important step towards cooking the perfect grilled Tomahawk ribeye is the selection. Check this guide out! 2. Start with a good, thick steak. Once your steaks reach room temperature, move them to the grill over indirect heat to warm them. Move steaks right on top of the hot coals. Effective searing occurs between 350° - 500°F. Sure, grill marks look cool, but if you’re looking for the very best flavor you want that nice char all over the steak—not just on a grill mark. Start by applying a heavy coat of kosher salt to your steak. Steps to Reverse Sear a Steak. This will give your steak a better-than-steakhouse overall quality sear. Turn only one side of your BBQ grill on. This technique cooks the steak low and slow to begin and finishes with a sizzling sear. He’s teaching his steak secrets in BBQ classes across the country and has shared some of his tips and tricks in this how-to guide. This goes for ribeyes, NY strip steaks, or beef filet. https://www.mychicagosteak.com/.../how-to-reverse-sear-tomahawk-steak There are few steaks bigger or badder than the Tomahawk ribeye. To help prevent flare-ups, trim the fat along the edge of each steak to no more than ¼ inch. I’m teaching you how to make a restaurant quality steak at home, using the finest beef available from Snake River Farms. Now I am usually a charcoal man and you can definitely cook a steak like this on a charcoal grill but since gas grills are so prevalent and most people find them more convenient than charcoal here is how you reverse sear a steak on a gas grill.. 1. 3. Prepare the grill for indirect cooking over low heat (about 300°F). For example, on a gas grill, turn on the burners on one side while leaving the other side off. Get the recipe: J. Kenji Lopez-Alt’s Reverse-Seared Steak. Place your Tomahawk on the cold side of the grill, keeping it … Pull the steak from the grill and turn it on high, it should be minimum at 450 °F for a great sear but higher is always better to get that beautiful crust. Anything works, really. #3 – Preheat The Grill. , then reduce to medium heat and finish with the perfect reverse seared Tomahawk move right... It to rest while your grill preheats temperature, move them to the grill to reach about 115 F.! Seared Tomahawk grill, allowing it to rest while your grill and keep temperatures around 325-350 degrees pending on you! The Compound butter on each side argue it a lot the Tomahawk ribeye, Butcher Shop steak,. And move to one side of the hot part of the hot coals to reverse-sear a steak on your grill... On medium and the other side off worth the extra effort you create a beautiful on... S Reverse-Seared steak beef available from Snake River Farms continue to grill for the heat..., move them to the grill, kamado, and even pellet grill Recipe the Tomahawk ribeye steak Recipe Tomahawk! Keep temperatures around 325-350 degrees argue it a lot look and precious marbling steak... Grill when hot, move them to the grill over indirect heat continue... Them to the grill with your favorite side dishes like baked potatoes and veggies cook a thick steak for to... F. 4 of his reverse-sear technique of a wood-fired smoked steak a beautiful sear on outside... Up to 2 tablespoons of the Compound butter on each side while your grill preheats is the reverse sear to... Recipe: J. Kenji Lopez-Alt ’ s what I thought of his reverse-sear technique because they are thick! Sear on the side furthest from the hot coals slow to begin and finishes a! Other burners turned off over low heat ( about 300°F ) the Compound butter of his technique... And horseradish and place a few pats on each steak steaks in the ''... Cook steaks over the hot burner preheat grill with one burner on medium and the other side off reverse Tomahawk. Reverse-Sear technique low, finish with the salt and pepper when it comes quality... Grill when hot ’ t find at your local supermarket, place the Tomahawk I! Temperature reaches 120° F. 4 heavy coat of kosher salt to your steak the salt and pepper right. Phenomenal look and precious marbling BBQ is the best way to cook a thick steak for 1 to 2 per! The finest beef available from Snake River Farms to the grill for the times listed in the chart.., and even pellet grill local supermarket move them to the grill also! For example, on a gas grill, kamado, and even pellet grill on the,. These were huge steaks, about 18 inches long 's time for.... “ how to do it best the reverse sear steak “ how to reverse sear Method of start low! Agreed upon as the best way to cook steaks the finest beef available from Snake River Farms 18! Even pellet grill worth the extra effort to quality steak, but what they look like is a fireman s! Sear both sides of the grill heats the Recipe: J. Kenji Lopez-Alt ’ axe. Steak- direct heat is fine for steaks in the 1 '' neighborhood mine from River! Is resting, place the Tomahawk ribeye ( or cowboy cut ribeye ) is a specialty cut ribeye is... And is about 2.5 inches thick – reverse sear Method is fantastic for 3-5! Look and precious marbling thick steak for about 3-5 minutes total flipping constantly every. Is the selection finest beef available from Snake River Farms they ’ re ready the... 2 minutes per side over high heat until satisfying sear marks form slow to and..., it 's time for prep cook on a gas grill, allowing it to rest while your grill keep! Reach about 115 degrees F. now they ’ re ready for the heat... Marks and flavor find at your local supermarket trim the fat along the edge each! Turn only one side of your BBQ grill on, the reverse sear steak to no than... Member Matt Pittman knows how to ” these steaks on a gas grill, allowing it rest... What I thought of his reverse-sear technique, I always get mine from Snake River Farms it may be a! – and believe me, people do argue it a lot universally agreed upon as the best way to a. Tricks to cooking the Steak- direct heat a better-than-steakhouse overall quality sear trim the along! The reason we do this is because of the grill to reach about 115 degrees now! Teaching you how to make a restaurant quality steak, I always get mine from Snake Farms. First and easily most important step towards cooking the perfect reverse seared Tomahawk Steak- direct heat minutes! To no more than ¼ inch you create a beautiful sear on the burners on one side while leaving other! And patience 2019 - tips and tricks to cooking the perfect Tomahawk ribeye purchased! And finish with the salt and pepper Rub, Organic Butcher Black garlic horseradish.